Payroll Responsibilities

Duty Department/Individual
Provides authorizations of employees and their pay rates  – Human resources
Oversees employees’ working hours (time cards)  – Timekeeping
Prepares the payroll register – Payroll
Prepares payment vouchers – Accounts payable
Approves the payments (signing checks) – Cash disbursement (CFO)
Records the payrolls – General ledger

Electronic Data Interchange

Electronic Data Interchange – EDI is the communication of electronic documents directly from a computer in one entity to a computer in another entity.

The advantages of using EDI are:

  1. Reduced clerical errors
  2. Increased speed
  3. Elimination of repetitive clerical tasks
  4. Elimination of document preparation, processing, filing, and mailing costs

An audit trail allows for the tracing of a transaction from initiation to disposition. One key element of an audit trail in transactions involving auditing electronic data interchange (EDI) is the activity log.

Sales – Receivables – Cash Receipts Cycle

Completeness assertion for sales and receivables
Reconciling total amounts in subsidiary ledgers with the general ledger
Performing analytical procedures (e.g., comparing accounts receivable turnover with previous year)
Accounting for the numerical sequence of sales orders, shipping documents, and invoices
Tracing from sales invoices to shipping documents

Accuracy assertion for sales and receivables 

Obtaining management representation letters
Evaluating disclosures about reportable operating segments (e.g., geographic areas)
Comparing general ledger balances with financial statement balances
Preparing bank reconciliations

Valuation and Allocation assertion for sales and receivables 

Comparing aged accounts receivables schedule with the prior year’s
Tracing subsequent cash receipts
Reviewing delinquent customers’ credit ratings
Testing the allowance for credit losses and write-offs

Existence assertion for sales and receivables 

Sending external confirmations
Vouching journals to shipping documents

Cutoff assertion for sales and receivables 

Sales cutoff – Testing whether revenue is recognized in the appropriate period
— Tracing shipping documents to accounting records near year end
Cash receipts cutoff – Testing the recording of cash receipts and accounts receivable reduction
— Tracing daily remittance list to accounting records near year end

Rights and Obligation assertion for sales and receivables 

Inquiring of management (e.g., whether the accounts receivable is pledged and factored)
Tracing cash receipts to deposits into bank accounts
Determining the right of return, expected returns, and actual returns

Occurrence assertion for sales and receivables 

Vouching samples of recorded sales transactions to customer orders and shipping documents

Classification and understandability assertion for sales and receivables
Evaluating
— Classification of
–Sales (minus returns and allowances) as revenue
— Accounts receivables (minus allowance) as current assets
Disclosures of
— Accounting policies
— Pledges and factoring of accounts receivables
— Sales and receivables with related parties

IT Controls – General and Application Controls

Types of Controls and Scope

General controls – The organization’s entire processing environment
Application controls – Particular to each of the organization’s applications

Three Categories of Application Controls are: 

Input controls
Processing controls
Output controls

Three types of controls classified by function are:

Preventive controls
Detective controls
Corrective controls

Input controls provide reasonable assurance that data submitted for processing are
Authorized
Complete
Accurate

Examples of Input Controls are:
Preformatting Entry in an online tax return
Edit (field) checks – Rejecting the input of letters for SSNs
Limit (reasonableness) checks –  Rejecting working hours of over 100 per week
Check digits – Using algorithms to verify ID numbers
Record count – Matching the number of time clock cards with the number of payroll records processed
Financial total – Matching the sum of individual salaries with total salaries
Hash total – Matching the sum of individual SSNs with a predetermined total

Processing controls provide reasonable assurance about:
Processing controls provide reasonable assurance that
All data submitted for processing are processed
Only approved data are processed

Examples of processing controls.
Control Description /Example
Validation Rejecting transactions by vendors whose vendor numbers are not in the vendor master file
Completeness check –  Rejecting records with missing data
Arithmetic controls – Zero-balance checking

Output controls provide assurance that processing was complete and accurate.

Control Description/Example
Audit trail Checking for the completeness of each process
Error listing Reporting all transactions rejected by the system

Components of Internal Control

Three Objectives of Internal Control are: 

Operations
—- Effectiveness and efficiency of operations
Reporting
— Reliability of financial reporting
Compliance
— Compliance with applicable laws and regulations

5 Components of Internal Control are:

Internal controls stop CRIME
Control activities Policies and procedures
Risk assessment process Identification and analysis of relevant risks
Information system Information systems and communication
Monitoring of controls Assessment of control effectiveness over time and corrective actions
Control environment Tone at the top and control consciousness of members

Internal controls provide only reasonable assurance, but not absolute assurance, that an entity’s objectives are met.

Inherent Limitations of Internal Control are:

Human error (e.g., faulty human judgment)
Collusion
Management override
Cost and benefit constraint

Audit – Strategic Planning Issues

Documentation of Audit Plans include:

The overall audit strategy (basis of the audit plan)
Procedures to be performed
Risk assessment procedures
Further procedures
Other procedures
Involvement of specialists

Three aspects of audit procedures should be documented in audit plans are:
NET of procedures
N = Nature
E = Extent
T = Timing

Factors external auditors consider before using the work of internal auditors are:
The objectivity of the internal auditors
The level of competence of the internal audit function
Whether the internal audit function applies a systematic and disciplined approach

Factors auditors consider before using the work of a specialist are:
The auditor should evaluate whether the auditor’s or management’s specialist has the necessary
Competence,
Capabilities, and
Objectivity.

Transactions that may suggest related-party transactions are:
Exchanging property for similar property in a nonmonetary transaction
Borrowing or lending at rates significantly above or below market rates
Selling realty at a price materially different from its appraised value
Making loans with no scheduled repayment terms

Accounting estimates
The objective of the auditor is to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence about whether accounting estimates, including fair value accounting estimates, are reasonable and related disclosures are adequate. This is achieved by determining whether
Management has appropriately applied the applicable financial reporting framework
The methods for making the accounting estimates are appropriate and have been applied consistently
The estimates, individually or collectively, exhibit no significant management bias

Audit Planning and Risk Assessment

[A] Pre-Engagement Acceptance Responsibilities

1) Preconditions for an Audit – Auditor to determine that management uses

  1. Acceptable financial reporting framework
  2. Understands its responsibility for the preparation and fair presentation of financial statements
  3. Understands its responsibility for the design, implementation and maintenance of internal control and
  4. Understands its responsibility to provide access to all information

2) Client Acceptance
It is continuous evaluation of existing clients and evaluation of new clients

  1. Successor Auditor is responsible for initiating the communication and is required to communicate with the predecessor auditor BEFORE accepting the engagement
  2. Successor auditor to consider the implications in event of client’s refusal to grant permission or predecessor auditor’s failure to respond fully
  3. Establish an understanding with the client regarding services to be performed

3) Engagement Letter –
Engagement Letter to include audit scope, limitations, expectations, fees and responsibilities of  management for services

[B] Planning an Audit

Planning – Overall strategy for the audit (Size and complexity of the entity, Auditor’s experience and Auditor’s understanding and environment of the entity including internal control)

Audit Plan (Nature, timing and extent of procedures expected to reduce audit risk to an acceptably low level). Audit Plan includes a description of risk assessment procedures directed toward the risk of material misstatement. Risk assessment procedures are performed to obtain an understanding of the entity and its environment, including its internal control, to identify and assess the risks of material misstatements at the a) Financial statements as a whole and b) Relevant assertions

Supervision – 1) Directing the efforts of assistants  in accomplishing the objectives of the audit ; 2) Determine if the objectives were accomplished. – a) Instructions ; b) Informed of problems encountered ; c) Reviewing the work ; d) Resolving differences of opinion
Differences  of Opinion – a) Assistant to document his / her disagreement with the conclusion reached  b) Document the basis of final resolution

Internal Audit Plans – Internal auditor’s work is more comprehensive. They are more detailed and cover areas that normally are not considered by the independent auditor

[C] Audit Risk and Materiality

[1] Audit Risk – Risk that the auditor expresses an inappropriate audit opinion when the financial statements are materially misstated
3 components of Audit Risk :
a) Inherent Risk – Susceptibility of an assertion to material misstatement in absence of related controls
b) Control Risk –
Risk that internal control will not prevent or detect on a timely basis a material misstatement
c) Detection Risk –
 Auditor will not detect a material misstatement that exists. It is a function of audit effectiveness of an audit procedure and its application by the auditor.

[2] Materiality – Materiality is a matter of professional judgement about whether misstatements could reasonable influence the economic decisions of users as group.
Materiality – Planning Purpose :
1. Financial Statement level as a whole
2. Particular account balances, classes of transactions or disclosures
3. Performance Materiality
Audit Risk and Materiality have an Inverse Relationship


The risk of a large misstatement may be low, but the risk of a small misstatement may be high
Auditor is required to perform atleast one of the following:
a) Perform Effective Procedures
b) Perform Procedures nearer to year end
c) Increase the extent of certain procedures

[3] Evaluating Findings – Considers the individual and aggregate effects of misstatements. Likely misstatements not merely known misstatements.

[4] Documentation – Document a) Amount of Misstatement that are trivial ; b) All Misstatements accumulated ; c) Whether misstatements are corrected ; d) Basis of conclusion that the uncorrected misstatements are material

[D] Understanding the Entity and its Environment

1) Auditor to obtain a sufficient understanding of the entity and its environment including its internal control
2) Auditor need not acquire this understanding PRIOR to acceptance of the engagement
3) Knowledge may be obtained from a variety of sources :
a) Prior year working papers ; b) Inquiries of entity personnel ; c) Experience with the entity or its industry ; d) AICPA Accounting and Audit Guides, industry publication and periodicals etc.
4) Risk Assessment Procedures – a) Inquiries of management and others within the entity ; b) Analytical Procedures ; Observation and Inspection

[E] Analytical Procedures

1) Evaluation of financial information made by study of plausible relationship among both financial and non financial data
2) Significant differences between expectations and recorded amounts should be investigated and evaluated
3) Analytical Procedures are : 1) Required to be used as risk assessment procedures in PLANNING

4) PERMITTED but NOT REQUIRED to be applied as SUBSTANTIVE TESTS

5) REQUIRED to be used in the FINAL REVIEW STAGE of the audit

[F]  Risk Assessment Procedures
a) Improve the understanding of the client’s business and significant transactions and events since the last audit
b) Identify unusual transactions or events and amounts, ratios and trends that might indicate matters with audit planning implications
c) Auditor develops expectations of recorded balances from  a) Comparable prior periods ; b) Budgets or Forecasts ; c) Relationship among data ; d) Information from Client’s Industry ; e) Related non financial information
d) Analytical Procedures applied as Substantive Tests : a) The nature of assertion ; b) Plausibility and predictability of relationship ; c) Availability and reliability of data ; d) Precision of the expectations
e) Analytical Procedures used in Final Review Stage – a) Assess conclusions and overall financial statement presentation ; b) Read financial statement and notes – (i) Adequacy of Evidence in response to unusual balances identified in planning or conducting the audit ; (ii) Unusual or unexpected balances not previously identified

[G] Ratio Analysis – a) Unexpected changes in ratios ; b) Potential explanation of changes in ratio
1) Current Ratio = Current Assets / Current Liabilities
2) Quick (Acid Test Ratio) = (Current Assets – Inventory)/Current Liabilities
3) Receivables Turnover = Net Sales / Average Net Receivables
4) Day’s Sales in Receivables = 365, 360, 300 / Receivables Turnover
5) Inventory Turnover = Cost of Goods Sold / Average Inventory
6) Day’s Sales in Inventory = 365, 360, 300 / Inventory Turnover
7) Total Assets Turnover = Net Sales / Total Assets
8) Debt to Equity Ratio = Total Debt / Total Equity
9) Times Interest Earned = (Net Income + Int Exp + Income Tax) / Interest Expense
10) Cost of Goods Sold = Cost of Goods Sold / Net Sales
11) Gross Margin Percentage = (Net Sales – Cost of Goods Sold) / Net Sales
12) Net Operating Margin Percentage = Operating Income / Sales
13) Return on Equity = Net Income / Total Equity

[H] Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement

1) Management is responsible for programs and controls that prevent, deter and detect fraud
2) Management and oversight authorities must set the proper tone and maintain a culture of honesty
3) Auditor cannot obtain absolute assurance that material misstatements will be detected because of characteristics of fraud and limitations of audit evidence
4) Properly planned audit may NOT detect a material misstatement resulting from fraud because of : a) Concealment aspects of fraudulent activity ; b) Control overriding by Management; c) Altering accounting records or withholding evidence ; d) Professional Judgement in identification and evaluation of fraud risks
5) Fraud differs from Error because it is intentional – a) Fraud involves pressures or incentives to commit fraud, perceived opportunity to do so and capacity to rationalize
6) Types of Fraud – a) Fraudulent financial reporting (Intentional misstatements or omissions to deceive users) ; b) Misappropriation of Assets (Theft, embezzlement that causes Financial Statements to be materially misstated)
7) Professional Scepticism – Auditor to a) Critically assess evidence ; b) continually question whether fraud has occurred ; c) Not accept unpersuasive evidence solely because management is believed to be honest
8) Assessment of Risks –
9) Evaluation of Audit Test Results –
a) If discovered fraud is not material ; b) If discovered fraud is material or evaluation is impossible ; c) If the risk of fraud is significant.
10) Communication of Fraud – a) Inconsequential Fraud to appropriate level of management; b) Fraud involving senior management to those charged with governance

[I] Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an audit of financial statements

1) Noncompliance is a violation of laws or governmental regulations
2) Auditor to consider the laws and regulations that are having a direct and material effect on the financial statements
3) An audit provides NO assurance that they will be detected or that any contingent liabilities that may result will be disclosed
4) If the noncompliance a) has a material effect on the financial statements or b) The client does not take the remedial action , auditor express a Qualified or adverse opinion or withdraw from the engagement
5) Disclosure of possible noncompliance to outside parties is NOT the auditor’s responsibility
6) Auditor may need to disclose while : a) Complying with legal and regulatory requirements ; b) Communicating with successor auditor ; c) Responding to Subpoena ; d) Reporting to funding or other specified agency

Professional Responsibilities

AICPA Code of Professional Conduct has a set of specific mandatory rules describing minimum levels of conduct a member must maintain as a CPA Profession has a responsibility to the public. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct expects the CPA to honour public trust

Rules that are mandatory for all members are :

(a) Integrity and Objectivity

(b) General Standards

(c) Compliance with Standards

(d) Accounting Principles

(e) Acts Discreditable

(f) Forms of Organization and Names

Rules that are mandatory for members in Public Practice only are :

(a) Independence

(b) Confidential Client Information

(c) Contingent Fees

(d) Advertising and other form of fees

(e) Commission and Referral Fees 

[1] Independence

Member in Public practice must be independent as required by standards setting bodies (AICPA, SEC, PCAOB, GAO)

– Independence in Mind (Intellectually Honest)

– Independence in Appearance (Free from any obligation to or interest in the client, management or owners)

Independence is impaired if Covered member has certain interests or relationships

Covered Member

Below are considered to be covered members:

  1. Individual on an attest engagement team or who can influence the engagement
  2. A partner or manager who provides at least 10 hours of non attest services
  3. A partner in the office where the lead engagement partner primarily practices in relation to the engagement
  4. The accounting firm
  5. An entity that can be controlled by foregoing parties

Impairment of Independence

A covered member MUST NOT

  1. Have a direct financial interest in the client, even if immaterial
  2. Have a material indirect financial interest in a client
  3. Loans to or from an attest client or its officers, directors, or 10% (or greater) owners during the period of the engagement
  4. Trustee of a Trust or Executor of an estate that has a direct or material indirect interest in a client
  5. Have a material joint, closely held investment with a client
  6. He / family member is associated with the client as an officer, diector, manager, employee, promoter or underwriter
  7. His close relative holds key position with the client
  8. Has financial interests in non clients having investor or investee relationships with the client

Materiality is determined by aggregating the interests of the covered member and his / her immediate family

Independence is not impaired by Grandfathered unsecured Loans that are not Material to the covered member’s net worth or secured loans provided that the loans were obtained from a financial institution under its normal lending procedures, terms and requirements

Permitted Loans

Loans obtained under the normal lending procedures, terms and requirements:

  1. Automobile Loans
  2. Loans fully collateralized by the cash surrender value of insurance / cash deposits
  3. Credit Cards with aggregate outstanding balance of $5,000/- or less by the payment due date (SEC permits credit card balance upto $ 10,000)

 Firm’s Independence is impaired if :

  1. Firm partner or professional employee owns more than 5% of a client
  2. A former partner or professional employee of the firm is employed by or associated with attest client in key position
  3. Non attest services are performed for an attest client

Firm’s Independence is NOT Impaired by providing the following services:

  1. Consulting Services
  2. Tax Preparation and Compliance services
  3. Business risk advising service
  4. Providing general advice based on audit findings

Independence is NOT Impaired for ATTEST engagements of NONISSUERS  by :

  1. Providing book keeping service
  2. Prepare client financial statements based on information in a Trial Balance
  3. Payroll Processing
  4. Record keeping functions

Independence is NOT impaired if :

  • Member in Honarary Position is associated with FS of a not for profit organization that he allows to use his name in the letterhead. He cannot vote or participate in board or management decisions
  • Independence is not impaired when the litigation is not related to the work product and is not material eg. dispute over billing
  • If the CPA has been retained as the auditor of the credit union of which CPA is  member, his independence is not impaired
  • Auditors checking account which is fully insured by the federal agency which is held at a clients financial institution – auditor is considered independent
  • Being an advisor to the client’s Board of Trustees does not impair an auditors independence
  • Independence is not impaired when a bank subsidiary in the consolidated group provides asset custody services in the ordinary course of business to an attest client of a new CPA Firm
  • Designing of an information system that is unrelated to the accounting records does not impair auditor independence

Unpaid fees owed by attest client to a covered member for professional service may impair independence.

[2] Integrity and Objectivity

Member shall :
a) Maintain Objectivity and Integrity
b) Free of Conflicts of Intersts
c) Not knowingly misrepresent facts
d) Not subordinate his / her judgements to others

[3] Professional Standards

 A member shall :
a) Take Services which he can complete with Professional Competence
b) Exercise Due Professional Care
c) Adequately Plan and Supervise performance
d) Obtain Sufficient relevant date to provide reasonable basis for conclusion
* Compliance with standards
* Accounting Principles

[4] Other Responsibilities

 Acts Discreditable :
1) Failure to return records upon requests
2) Discrimination and Harassment
3) Failure to follow the requirements of governmental bodies
4) Failure to follow applicable audit standards

Response to Requests for Records :
Client provided records must be returned even if:
a) Fees have not been paid
b) The state in which the member practices grants a lien on certain records

Type of Record                   Right to Withhold
Client provided record             None
Working Papers                         Absolute
Member prepared Records     If fee due
Supporting records                   If fee due

Advertisement and Other Forms of Solicitation
Member shall not seek to obtain clients by advertising or other forms of solicitation done in false, misleading and deceptive manner

Contingent Fee
Receipt of contingent fee is prohibited when auditors report will be used by third parties and the report does not disclose CPA’s lack of independence

Member shall NOT prepare for a contingent fee:
a) Original Tax Return
b) Amended Tax Return
c) Claim for a Tax Refund

Fees are not considerd to be contingent if :
a) They are fixed by public authorities  (eg. courts)
b) In tax matters, they are based on the results of judicial proceedings or the findings of governmental agencies  

[5] Other Pronouncements on Professional Responsibilities

Sarbenes-Oxley, PCAOB and SEC :
[1] Preapproval of Services : 1) Audit Committee must preapprove the services performed by accountants.
[2] Disclosure of Fees : An issuer must disclose in its proxy statement or annual filing fees paid for the accountant segregated into 4 categories : 1) Audit ; 2) Audit related ; 3) Tax ; 4) All other
[3] Rotation of Partners : The lead and concurring (reviewing) partner must rotate every 5 years with a 5 year time out period
Other partners must rotate every 7 years with a 2 year time out period
Auditors to maintain their audit working papers for 7 years
[4] Communication with Audit Committee : 1) All critical accounting policies and practices to be used ; 2) All material alternative treatments of financial information within GAAP discussed with the management ; 3) Ramification of the use of alternative disclosures and treatments  ; 4) Treatment preferred by the accountant
[5] Material Departure from GAAP :
is permitted when a) The financial statements or data would have been misleading without a departure from GAAP due to the unusual circumstances / new legislation or evaluation of a new form of business transaction exists
[6] Prohibited Non Audit Services :
The firm is prohibited from certain non audit services to their attest clients, including 1) Management services ; 2) Booking ; 3) HR ; 4) Internal Audit ; 5) Appraisal or Valuation ; 6) Expert services ; 7) Broker-Dealer ; 8) Designing and Implementing financial information system ; 9) Investment banking or advisory ; 10) Hosting service ; 11) Expert witness
Conflict of Interest may be permitted in certain circumstances if DISCLOSURE is made to and CONSENT  is obtained from the appropriate parties
[7] Audit Committee : Each member of the audit committee MUST BE INDEPENDENT member of the BOD and directly responsible for appointing, compensating and overseeing the work of the auditor and must have one member designated as financial expert

Engagement Responsibilities

Audit Engagements

  • Purpose of Audit is to provide users of financial with an opinion on whether the financial statements are presented fairly, in all material respects in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework
  • Objective of Audit  is to (1) Obtain reasonable assurance  (2) Express an Opinion  (3) Report findings as required by GAAS (4) Be Independent and comply with relevant ethical rules
  • Auditor to (1) Exercise professional judgement (2) With Professional Skepticism (3) Recognize that circumstances may exist that may cause the financial statements to be materially misstated (4) Obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to reduce audit risk to an acceptably low level (5) Auditors opinion enhances the degree of confidence that intended users can place in financial statements (6) Auditor uses relevant assertions to form a basis for the assessment of risks of material misstatements (RMM)
  • Professional Skepticism includes a (1) A questioning mind (2) Alertness to conditions that may indicate material misstatement (3) Critical assessment of audit evidence
  • Auditing Standards are concerned with (1) Quality of Audit Performance (2) Objectives to be attained. Generally accepted auditing standards are established by Auditing Standards Board and Public Company Accounting Oversight Board
  • Auditing Interpretation are issued by Audit Issue Task Force of Auditing Standard Board (ASB) to provide timely guidance on the application of pronouncement of the ASB. They are not auditing standards.

Management Assertions

  • Management Assertions on Financial Statements are for its (1) Completeness (2) Accuracy (3) Valuation & Allocation (4) Existence (5) Classification & Understandability (6) Rights & Obligations (7) Occurrence (8) Cutoff

Professional Responsibilities

1) Unconditional Requirements – Use of word ‘Must’ – Auditor must comply with an unconditional requirement

2) Presumptively Mandatory Requirements Use of  word – ‘Should’ .When an auditor decides that such a departure is necessary, he/she should perform alternative audit procedures to achieve intent of the requirement

3) Word – May / Might / Could  – Actions and Procedures that the auditor should use professional judgement in determining whether to perform

Accounting and Review Engagements

Preparation – It is a non-attest service and the accountant need not (1) verify the accuracy or completeness of management information (2) obtain evidence to express an opinion or conclusion (c) report on the financial statements

Preparation of financial statements requires compliance with Statements for Accounting and Review Services

Compilation – It is presentation in statement form of information without expressing any assurance thereon. It requires the accountant to (a) Determine that he is independent (b) Report on statements (c) Disclaim any assurance (d) Disclose any lack of independence and (e) Associate his name with the statements

Review – Objective is to obtain Limited Assurance as a basis of reporting if any material modification should be made to the statements. (a) Performed primarily through inquiry and analytical procedures (b) It is also known as negative assurance (c) Review does not contemplate consider internal controls (d) Review does not contemplate tests of transactions and account balances (e) Review does not contemplate other auditing procedures (f) Must issue a report

Attestation Engagements

CPA is engaged to issue an examination, a review or an agreed upon procedures report on the subject matter [point in time / period in time] which is the responsibility of another party. Example – (a) Historical or prospective performance or condition (b) Physical characteristics (c) Historical events (d) Analysis (e) Systems and Processes (f) Behavior

Independence is required for all attestation engagements.  Written Assertion is required for Examination and Review but is not required for Agreed Upon Procedures. Opinion for is required for Examination and findings of specific procedure for Agreed Upon Procedures. Level of Assurance is High for Examination and Limited for Review. Working Papers are required  for all attestation engagements.

Additional Professional Services

Assurance Services – Provides independent and professional opinions that reduce information risk (risk from incorrect information). Assurance services do not include

Assurance services do not require written assertions, unless services fall under AICPA’s attestation standards.

Consulting Services – They are professional services that use practitioner’s technical skills, education, observation, experiences and knowledge of consulting process. Should inform client of significant engagement findings. Primary objective is to provide the client with better outcomes through recommendations based on objectives of the engagement.

Quality Control

Quality control applies to Firms practice as a whole.

6 Elements of Quality Control are (1) Tone at the Top (2) Relevant Ethical Requirements (3) Acceptance and continuance of clients and engagements (4) Personnel Management (5) Engagement Performance (6) Monitoring

Peer Review

It is necessary part of the practice monitoring requirement for AICPA membership

Sarbens Oxley Act 2002

SOX is applicable to audit of public companies. Provision of SOX relate to improving quality control of audit and financial reporting. It requires second partner review and approval of audit reports. Lead auditor and reviewing partner must be rotated off audit every 5 years. CEO and CFO must certify the appropriateness of the financial statements and disclosures

Public Companies Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) 

Required for audit of an issuer. Objective of reviewer is to evaluate the significant judgements made and related conclusions reached. The reviewer should evaluate (a) Assessment of and responses to significant risks (b) Engagement completion document and whether unresolved matters are significant (c) Significant judgements about planning matters

 

Assurance Services differs from Consulting service in 2 ways:

  1. a) Assurance focus is on improving information rather than providing advice;
  2. b) Assurance involves 2 party arrangements where one want to monitor another.

 

Covid 19 – Statutory & Regulatory Compliances

Following are several important relief measures taken by the Government of India in view of COVID-19 outbreak, especially on statutory and regulatory compliance matters related to several sectors:—

A. INCOME TAX 

[1] Income Tax Extend last date for income tax returns for (FY 18-19) from 31st March, 2020  to  30th June, 2020.

[2] Aadhaar-PAN linking date to be extended from 31st March, 2020 to 30th June, 2020.

[3] Vivad se Vishwas  scheme – no additional 10% amount, if payment made by June 30, 2020.

[4] Due dates for  issue  of notice, intimation, notification, approval order, sanction order, filing of appeal, furnishing of return, statements, applications, reports, any other documents and time limit for completion of proceedings by the authority and any compliance by the taxpayer including investment in saving instruments or investments for roll over benefit of capital gains under Income Tax Act,  Wealth Tax Act, Prohibition of Benami Property Transaction Act, Black Money Act,  STT law, CTT Law, Equalization Levy law, Vivad Se Vishwas  law  where the time limit is expiring between 20th March 2020  to 29th June 2020 shall be extended to 30th June 2020.

[5] For delayed payments of advanced tax, self-assessment tax,  regular tax, TDS, TCS, equalization levy, STT, CTT  made between 20th March 2020  and  30th June 2020,  reduced interest rate  at 9%   instead of 12 %/18 % per annum ( i.e. 0.75% per month instead of 1/1.5 percent per month) will be charged  for this period.  No late fee/penalty shall be charged for delay relating to this period.

[6] Necessary legal circulars and legislative amendments for giving effect to the aforesaid relief shall be issued in due course.

B. GST / Indirect Tax

[1] Those having aggregate annual turnover less than Rs. 5 Crore Last date can file  GSTR-3B due in March, April and May 2020  by the last week of  June, 2020. No interest, late fee, and penalty to be charged.

[2] Others can file returns due in March, April and May 2020 by last week of June 2020  but the same would attract reduced rate of interest @9 % per annum from  15 days after due date (current interest rate is  18 % per annum). No late fee and penalty to be charged, if complied before till 30th June 2020.

[3] Date for opting for composition scheme is extended till the last week of   June, 2020.  Further, the last date for making payments for the quarter ending 31st March, 2020 and filing of  return for 2019-20 by the composition dealers  will be extended  till the last week of June, 2020.

[4] Date for filing GST annual returns of FY 18-19, which is due on 31st March, 2020 is extended till the last week of  June 2020.

[5] Due date for issue of notice, notification, approval order, sanction order, filing of appeal, furnishing of return, statements, applications, reports, any other documents, time limit for any compliance under the GST laws where the time limit is expiring between 20th March 2020  to 29th June 2020 shall be extended to 30th June 2020.

[6] Necessary legal circulars and legislative amendments to give effect  to the aforesaid GST relief shall follow with the approval of GST Council.

[7] Payment date under Sabka Vishwas Scheme shall be extended to 30th June, 2020. No interest for this period shall be charged if paid by 30th June, 2020.

C. CUSTOMS

[1] 24X7 Custom clearance till end of 30th June, 2020.

[2] Due date for issue of notice, notification, approval order, sanction order, filing of appeal, furnishing applications, reports, any other documents etc., time limit for any compliance under the Customs Act and other allied Laws where the time limit is expiring between 20th March 2020  to 29th June 2020 shall be extended to 30th June 2020.

D. FINANCIAL SERVICES

[1]  Relaxations for 3 months Debit cardholders to withdraw cash for free from any other banks’ ATM for 3 months.

[2] Waiver of minimum balance fee Reduced bank charges for digital trade transactions for all trade finance consumers.

E. CORPORATE AFFAIRS 

[1] No additional fees shall be charged for late filing during a moratorium period from 01st April to 30th September 2020, in respect of any document, return, statement etc., required to be filed in the MCA-21 Registry, irrespective of its due date, which will not only reduce the compliance burden, including financial burden of companies / LLPs at large, but also enable long-standing non-compliant companies/ LLPs to make a ‘fresh start’.

[2] The mandatory requirement of holding meetings of the Board of the companies within prescribed interval provided in the Companies Act (120 days), 2013, shall be extended by a period of 60 days till next two quarters i.e., till 30th September;

[3] Applicability of Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020 shall be made applicable from the financial year 2020-2021 instead of from 2019-2020 notified earlier. This will significantly ease the burden on companies & their auditors for the year 2019-20.

[4] As per Schedule 4 to the Companies Act, 2013, Independent Directors are required to hold at least one meeting without the attendance of Non-independent directors and members of management. For the year 2019-20, if the IDs of a company have not been able to hold even one meeting, the same shall not be viewed as a violation.

[5] Requirement to create a Deposit reserve of 20% of deposits maturing during the financial year 2020-21 before 30th April 2020 shall be allowed to be complied with till 30th June 2020.

[6] Requirement to invest 15% of debentures maturing during a particular year in specified instruments before 30th April 2020, may be done so before 30th June 2020.

[7] Newly incorporated companies are required to file a declaration for Commencement of Business within 6 months of incorporation. An additional time of 6 more months shall be allowed.

[8] Non-compliance of minimum residency in India for a period of at least 182 days by at least one director of every company, under Section 149 of the Companies Act, shall not be treated as a violation.

[9] Due to the emerging financial distress faced by most companies on account of the large-scale economic distress caused by COVID 19, it has been decided to raise the threshold of default under section 4 of the IBC 2016 to Rs 1 crore (from the existing threshold of Rs 1 lakh). This will by and large prevent triggering of insolvency proceedings against MSMEs. If the current situation continues beyond 30th of April 2020, we may consider suspending section 7, 9 and 10 of the IBC 2016 for a period of 6 months so as to stop companies at large from being forced into insolvency proceedings in such force majeure causes of default.

Detailed notifications/circulars in this regard shall be issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs separately.